Welcome to the website of Black Button Eyes Productions, a Chicago theatre company! Our 2025 show is now playing: a coproduction with City Lit Theater Company. Ed has directed the world premiere of Timothy Griffin’s play Strange Cargo: The Doom of the Demeter, an adaptation of a chapter from Bram Stoker’s Dracula! The show is Jeff Recommended and is being celebrated by critics and audience alike. Individual tickets can be purchased here!

[THREE STARS] [Playwright Timothy] Griffin puts imaginative twists on Stoker’s limited source material...a worthwhile way to kick off my seasonable lineup of spooky shows.
— Emily McClanathan, Chicago Tribune
[READER RECOMMENDED] A moody, macabre horror tale for the Halloween season. The solid ten-member ensemble …is buoyed by imaginative and well-integrated design work.
— Albert Williams, Chicago Reader
Perfectly presented during the Halloween season, City Lit’s co-production with Black Button Eyes Productions is an absolutely timely artistic pairing… without a doubt, this horrifying legend of Dracula will forever be remembered as one of City Lit’s finest productions.
— Colin Douglas, Chicago Theatre Review
This world premiere presentation, directed by Ed Rutherford, is perfect for the Halloween season!...There are lots of nicely conceived and executed surprises throughout the show.
— Julia Rath, Around the Town Chicago
The crew tells their ghost story, a tale of horror written in the captain’s log and other details too terrible to commit to paper, with both acting verve and design finesse…a perfect spooky season treat. I would happily sit for their tale again.
— Robert Eric Shoemaker, New City Stage
The production, directed by Ed Rutherford, does a strong job in carrying out an interesting concept that largely succeeds…Griffin overall delivers a compelling narrative.
— Christine Malcolm, Talkin’ Broadway
This has the makings of a great recurring seasonal show for Halloween…fun to watch.
— Bill Eisler, Buzz Chicago
A fine choice for those seeking Halloween drama… Let it shake your bones for this scary season.
— Mara Tapp